enlace Educamadrid
Escuela Oficial de Idiomas de Collaldo_Villalba
enlace Comunidad de Madrid
inicio
secretaría
servicios
curso actual
enseñanzas
That's English
actividades
galería de fotos
trabajo
enlaces
mapa del web
escríbenos
 
 
 

SERVICIOS > biblioteca > opiniones > A Christmas Carol

"A Christmas Carol " by Charles Dickens

 A Christmas Carol

Ebenezer Scrooge is a mean old man. He lives in London and he is a businessman. He hates Christmas because he thinks that Christmas is a humbug so he doesn’t want to celebrate Christmas with his family.

But on Christmas Eve, three spirits visit him. The first of the spirits of Christmas Past, they go to the past and Scrooge and the spirit see the last Christmas when Scrooge liked it.

After the spirits of Christmas Present appears. With the spirit Scrooge walks along the streets in London, and he sees, his clerk. He is celebrating Christmas with his family, they are poor but they are happy together although Bob´s son Tiny Tin is ill.

Then Scrooge is visited by the spirits of Christmas Future . The spirit shows him the future ,Tiny Tin is dead and Scrooge is dead too, he sees a grave with his name, but nobody remembers him as a good person.

With the spirits Scrooge thinks and he says that he will keep Christmas in his heart. At the end of story Tiny Tin doesn’t die and Scrooge is a kind person, he helps the poor, and he always celebrates Christmas with his nephew.

PERSONAL OPINION

This book is a fantastic Christmas story. In this book Christmas is a happy time when the people eat with the family. But actually we spend much money. We are very generous at Christmas, but why aren’t generous every year?

My favourite character is Scrooge’s nephew, Fred. Although his uncle doesn’t want to celebrate Christmas, he always invites his uncle. Fred is very kind, funny and he loves his family. He is a good character! But I don’t like Scrooge although he changes, he is mean, moody and he doesn’t love his life.

I like this book, it is reason, and Dickens writes very well this novel, he describes London and the poor of the time, XIX. In this time the life was very difficult for people.

Sara Álvarez Lameiras


 Ebenezer Scrooge is a mean, miserable, cross old man. He doesn´t love anybody, he hasn´t got any friends, nobody is good enought for him. But he is happy, that is what he wants.

The night before Christmas day, his dead partner´s ghost, Jacob Marley; appears and it says to him: “If you don’t change yourself, you´ll finish like me, unable to have a good die. This night, three spirits´ll come here, one after other, and they´ll teach you the lesson you´ll never forget”.

 The first one is the ghost of Christmas Past, he shows Mr Scrooge how he was when he was a child, and his bad behaviour in Christmas.

 The second one, the ghost of Christmas Present, shows him how happy people are in Christmas, although they are poor.

 The third one, the ghost of Christmas Future, shows him his future life if he doesn´t change.

 After that, Mr. Scrooge decides to change and become the perfect man.

   

PERSONAL OPINION

 I like very much this book because it is a history that never ends, every year an Mr Scrooge appears, and fortunatelly, some “spirits” teach to him the good of life.

 I think it is a book where people can find the real sense of Christmas.

 My favourite character was Bob Cratchit. He is a man who knows to be good when things go bad, and he loves so much his family although they are lots of problems.

 This book has diferents versions, nowadays it still copying. I´d recommend it , I think people should read it.

Beatriz Iglesias


It was Christmas Eve, at three o´clock in the afternoon, and in London it was very cold and almost dark.

On top of the door of an office in the centre of London, there were two names painted: Scrooge and Marley. Jacob Marley had died seven years ago.

Scrooge wasn´t friendly and kind, he didn´t say hello to anybody when he was walking through the street, …

He didn´t have friends. Nobody visited him.

Scrooge thought Christmas was humbug.

He was working in his office with his clerk, Bob Cratchit. At that moment Scrooge´s nephew appeared to invited him to his house on Christmas Day, but Scrooge refused the invitation and said goodbye to his nephew. Later a gentleman came into the office and asked for money for the poor people who lived in prisons and workhouses, but Scrooge said goodbye to him and the gentleman left.

Then Scrooge decided to close the office and Bob and he went home.

In Scrooge´s house, suddenly Jacob Marley´s ghost appeared next to the fire and told Scrooge that the three other ghosts were going to appear that night. The Ghost of Christmas Past, The Ghost of Christmas Present and The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come. They were going to help him to be good and kind to other people so they could rest in peace, not like Marley.

 The Ghost of Christmas Past showed Scrooge how was Christmas when he was a teenager and why he became sadder. He had a girlfriend and he left her and he became an old and mean man who was only interested in the money.

 The Ghost of Christmas Present showed him how was Christmas in the present, but in other places of different families: The Cratchit´s house, Fred´s family and more. He saw how poor people could be happy with very little money. Here he started to have feelings looking at Bob´s life and the problem of his son, Tiny Tim.

 The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come showed him how his future would be.

Scrooge saw himself in his future grave and he realised nobody went to his funeral, because the people hated him.

 At that moment he promised the latest ghost that he was going to change. And he was a changed man because he gave money for poor people, …

 

 PERSONAL OPINION

I liked this story because it´s related to these days (Christmas Holiday) and it´s a very interesting story to amuse.

We also can know some customs about English people at Christmas: the parties, the food, …

It´s also important to mention the author of the story, Charles Dickens, for his great relevance in the English Literature.

 My favourite character, in this story, is Scrooge (the main character), because, in my opinion, he´s the realest character in the story and we can see how a sad and mean person can become a good, kind and generous person with the sweat of his brow.

 I don´t like very much Belinda (Bob´s wife) because she´s a plane character and she´s very bossy with her husband and she didn´t want to give another opportunity to Scrooge and everyone deserves a second opportunity.

 I advise this book because it´s a good method to learn English and it´s very interesting.

 Hugo Garlito

 

Plot:
Ebenezer Scrooge was a rich man, but he was a mean, old man. He hated Christmas, and he hated that people said " Merry Christmas" too. On Christmas Eve his nephew invited him to the Christmas´ dinner, but Scrooge answered that he didn´t go to dinner. His business´ partner , Marley was dead so Scrooge continued with the business alone. He was a hard, clever, mean and old man. People were afraid of him.
His clerk Bob Cratchit had a lot of children with his wife. Although Bob worked for Scrooge, he paid Bob a little, consequently bob was poor and his younger son was ill because Tiny Tim (his son) needed to eat more. If Tiny Tim didn´t eat more, he would die.
The night of Christmas´ Eve Scrooge went home and saw Marley´s ghost. Marley´s ghost said to him "If you don´t change you´ll die alone. Three spirits will come. The first spirit is going to come at one o´clock tonight, the second spirit at the same time the next night, and the third spirit at midnight the following night.
The first spirit showed him the past (his sister, …).
The second spirit showed him the present (his nephew, Bob´s family, Tiny Tim, …).
The third spirit showed him the future (Scrooge died alone, Tiny Tim died too and bob´s family were crying …).
When Scrooge got up he didn´t know which day it was, but later he knew that it was Christmas. He was happy because he could change the future and he wanted it. Scrooge began to like Christmas. He opened the window and he said to everybody "Merry Christmas". Scrooge bought a big turkey and gave it to Bob´s family. Finally he began to be kind with everybody, and he gave money for people who were poor. He went to dinner with his nephew.

Characters: Scrooge, his nephew, Marley´s ghost. The three spirits, Bob´s family, Tiny Tim, bob.

Why do you like the book?:
I like the book because it is interesting, and it has a good end.
I like it because it teaches us that we should be kind with other people and that we should be more generous with poor people and help these people.

MARTA SANZ DEL BURGO 2º B